After Arlo murders a Dixie Mafia member in prison, Raylan tells Art about the Panamanian diplomatic courier’s bag he found following a burglary of his dad’s house. But because Arlo refuses to talk, the marshals are left looking for Waldo Truth, the fugitive patriarch of a Kentucky crime family whose ID was found in the bag.
Meanwhile, Ellen May falls under the spell of Preacher Billy and his partner Cassie, despite being told to avoid them. And while he blames Billy for a recent drop in illicit drug sales, Boyd also finds evidence that a new heroin dealer in Harlan is working for Frankfort crime boss Wynn Duffy.
Raylan's search for Drew Thompson leads to his psychic widow, who claims to know nothing about the past.
As Raylan investigates a burglary, a new preacher’s ministry cuts into Boyd's drug trade.
Quarles takes desperate measures to raise some cash, the law catches up with Boyd over a murder, and Arlo's loose lips divulge all sorts of secrets.